What Makes Travel Abroad Unique, and Why Should Americans Do It?

11/6/09  Print This Post Print This Post    5 Comments      Written by Sarah Menkedick
    Share

Feature Photo: Paul Stevenson Photo: gabyu

Why is it so important to travelers and travel bloggers that Americans do or don’t travel abroad?

There’s plenty of reasoning about why Americans don’t travel abroad. Travel bloggers speculate on whether it’s fear of a big, scary world, or ignorance of other cultures, or short vacation time, or the simple fact that there’s a helluva lot of stuff to do in the U.S alone. It may be all of those factors combined, but that’s not what interests me. What interests me is the assumption behind all this speculation – the assumption that Americans should travel abroad.

At first I wanted to question that assumption, since I’ve met plenty of Americans who could (and happily would) tick off all of the countries they’ve visited, list all of the trials and tribulations and predictable breakthroughs they’ve had, rave about all the artwork and trinkets and objects they’ve bought and swoon over the precious simple authenticity of “the locals,” and I find nothing particularly revolutionary or educational about this at all.

In fact, I think it’s pretty much the same old dynamic between the U.S and the world multiplied once more – simple consumable experiences, the commodification of culture, the seeing-what-we’ve-been-primed-by-the-media-to-see vs. researching-what-is.

But I hope I’m not so cynical or so pompous as to completely disregard the potential of travel abroad – while I don’t see it as the panacea for twisted U.S foreign policy or the distorted views many Americans have of the world, I also think it holds enormous potential to create positive, constructive change. By “change” I mean change in the way Americans think about, say, where their coffee comes from, or change in the way they think about an American food culture that relies on an unhealthy dependence on processed corn and the microwave.

Photo: tiltti

I’ve met plenty of people who have gone through transformations abroad and started, little by little, to see their world and the world overall from different angles. They’ve perhaps started to follow the news about China or Mexico much more carefully and to search out different perspectives. They’ve become aware of the affect of U.S corn subsidies on the people they met and talked to in Southern Mexican villages. They see that wow, I have a lot of stuff in my house and these people, they seem to be doing just fine without having to go to Target every other day for a new something.

This is not, of course, a given. I don’t think anyone has the right to declare what a traveler should or should not learn, should or should not see. But I have met plenty of Americans who have been prying into their own assumptions and accepted ways of understanding the world, taking apart their own cultural perspectives, and coming away with a much more complicated, empathetic understanding of the connections between themselves and the places they’ve visited.

And I think that process, of empathizing with people from vastly different cultural, social and economic perspectives, is at the heart of traveling abroad. That is what often distinguishes travel abroad from domestic travel – travel abroad requires so many more leaps into the unknown.

There are the major unknowns, the unknown languages and cultures and histories, but there are also the smaller unknowns; how rice or sugar cane is made, the herbs people use for medicines, the deserted villages where people have been forced to migrate to other countries. And traveling abroad is the process of excavating these unknowns, of bringing them up to the surface of one’s mind, in the hope of creating some new bridge of empathy and compassion.

So I’m not sure it’s the percentages and the statistics that matter, I’m not sure it’s the act of getting one’s passport stamped – I think it’s the way of seeing and questioning that makes travel abroad different, and that has so many people vehemently defending the act of crossing borders. It’s the push into the unknown, and the coming back humbled, contemplative, vulnerable, and yes, in ways both conscious and vaguely felt, changed.

Community Connection

What do you think, readers? Do you think travel abroad is inherently educational? What have been your experiences overseas? Do you think Americans are afraid of overseas travel?


    Share

About the Author

Matador ID: SarahMenkedick

Matador Contributing Editor Sarah Menkedick is a freelance writer based in Oaxaca, Mexico. Her writing has appeared in print and online publications, including Literary Traveler, Abroad View magazine, and National Geographic Glimpse. She has traveled, lived, and taught on five continents, and is constantly in pursuit of spicy food, dark beer, and new places to run. Check out her website of photography and creative nonfiction inspired by travel.

5 Comments... join the discussion!

  • joshua johnson replied on November 6, 2009

    for this American, international travel is what indeed remedied a narrow and yes, twisted view of the world. I was a post 9/11 patriot that wanted to drop bombs first and ask questions later. I was slightly bigoted, out for war and public education had left me with no reasonable view of the world at large. One backpacking trip took care of that.
    Because we the biggest footprint, Americans need to see the world they are treading on.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Christine Garvin replied on November 6, 2009

    I’m glad you brought up the important aspect of just because a person travels abroad does not necessarily make them less ignorant of other cultures, when it’s more about the commodity of travel than the experience itself. It kinda gets at the heart of why should people travel?

    As I was reading your piece, I thought about the short week I was in Zimbabwe (I was in Zambia for most of my African trip) and how that forever changed me around following the politics of another nation. Of course, there’s no way to keep up with all the intricacies of politics all over the world, but I think that in traveling for the sake of connecting to other people, each of us is deeply impacted by at least one place, and at least one tribe other than our own. And that can only help to make us recognize our oneness.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Turner replied on November 7, 2009

    Travel is the best school one can attend. Good stuff, Sarah.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Mara replied on November 7, 2009

    I think this is a great post. I know lots of people for whom travel is a way to show off or to complete some kind of checklist. It is definitely possible to go to the remotest corners of the globe and have one’s eyes and ears closed – after all, we do take ourselves with us everywhere we go, don’t we?

    Last winter I wrote a post in which I defended the relevance of travel, even in trying economic times. (It’s called “Is travel relevant? This mom says yes, and you can find it here: http://www.motherofalltrips.com/2009/02/is-travel-relevant-this-mom-says-yes.html). Most of the places I’ve gone with my kids wouldn’t be considered all that challenging or exotic by some of the other travelers I know. But I try to approach each new place with an open mind and an open heart. Traveling with kids definitely helps me to do that.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • mattnnz replied on April 13, 2010

    I think you are overly hard on people from the USA. There are 300 million of us. Some sinners, some saints with almost everyone else in between just trying to get by. One thing I find to be true is that everyone in the world is very similar in most ways. What is the use in all this self flagellation? Go out and experience the world and let it be what it is and let people be who they are. Be who you are. The learning can go both ways. It is not as if the USA has nothing to offer the rest of the world. We are a nation of immigrants who took a chance on a better life. That has got be worth something. I do agree that we have become far too fearful and as a result are turning away from freedom and toward control to be safe. Step outside and lightning is more likely to get you than terrorists.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:



Explore the Community



Popular Stories on Matador

10 Extraordinary Burial Ceremonies From Around The World

Not all cultures believe in burying the dead in the gro... 

The World Wide Wiener: Hot Dogs Around the World

Most people gravitate towards the Terimayo, a beef hot ... 

10 Tips For Managing Your Online Life While Traveling

... 

If Guidebooks Could Talk

Choosing the right 2D companion for your travels.... 

Meet a Matador Editor: Carlo Alcos

Meet Carlo Alcos, co-editor of Matador Trips. ... 

Essential Gear for the Nomadic Travel Photographer

Are you a serious travel photographer constantly on the... 

Notes on a Pilgrimage to the Bodhi Tree

Robert Hirschfield visits the Bodhi tree where "a man g... 

Ultimate Burning Man Packing List: 50+ Items To Bring To BRC

The first step to a successful trip to

Someday Syndrome & the System of I-Can’ts

Or why I left my five year old standing in a raging riv... 

How to Be Your Own Chai Wallah

Learn the skills of a chai wallah by creating your own ... 



Focus





Editor Blogs