Over Before It Starts: Life And Death In Mongolia

04/29/10  Print This Post Print This Post    7 Comments      Written by Andrew Cullen
    Share

Bayan Ulgii is Mongolia’s western-most province, set in the Altai mountains where Mongolia, China, and Russia converge. It is also the only province where Mongolians are not the majority: about 90 percent of the population is ethnically Kazakh.

The Islamic Kazakh community has a higher birthrate than its Mongolian neighbors, as well as one of the highest maternal mortality rates in the country. In 2008, Bayan Ulgii’s maternal mortality rate was 76.7 deaths per 100,000 live births, compared to the national average of 49 per 100,000 live births. And while infant mortality hovers near the national average, Mongolia as a whole has the 67th worst infant mortality rate in the world, according to the CIA’s 2009 estimate.

On a recent visit to Ulgii, I tried to learn more about the beginnings of life and premature death there.

In the central hospital’s maternity ward, I saw Soviet made equipment, decades old, waiting to be replaced. The hospital- the main source of intensive health care for the roughly 100,000 people in the province- generally sees a handful of births a day. The ward has only a few doctors and a handful of nurses on staff.

Although none of the women I talked to at the hospital complained about the care they received, I heard rumors from a number of people around town that the doctors of Bayan Ulgii do not always act professionally. Some blamed the low government salary doctors receive (currently the national doctors’ union, alongside the teachers’ and railroad workers’ unions, are in negotiations with the government and threatening to strike if their salaries aren’t doubled). Some said that the doctors may be drunk on the job; others told me that bribes, including gifts of vodka, were necessary to secure the best care.

The bribes aren’t necessarily solicited. “To be more safe, they will give money, then the doctor will check carefully,” one nurse’s husband (the couple themselves the parents of a healthy infant) told me.

Such rumors are unsubstantiated. The director of one INGO’s regional health project said, “It’s difficult, we can’t catch them. I haven’t seen them taking money, so I can’t say that they are. But I can say they are, because people are saying it.”

Bayan Ulgii’s head pediatrician, Khuatkhan, says that the hospital didn’t have all the essential resources it needed until October of 2009, when an $11,000 World Vision grant allowed them to purchase new equipment. The hospital’s facilities remain less than desirable.

“The children that died this year”- 19 in January and February alone- “had treatable conditions, if the hospital had sufficient funds, equipment, and medicine,” he says.

Medical facilities aside, the families of Bayan Ulgii face another obstacle to fighting infant and maternal mortality: poverty. Forty percent of the population is very poor, according to Khuatkhan. Severe malnutrition is common among the children treated in Bayan Ulgii’s hospital, as is anemia, which afflicts forty percent of mothers in the province.

Three months old, the boy has gained just 300 grams- less than a pound- since his birth. A health baby gains about 900 grams a month. He lives with his parents, both unemployed, in a one room mud plaster house. They own just five goats, and since the government suspended a program which provided families with a small monthly payment for each child a few months ago, survival has been a struggle. Local doctors who normally make house calls refuse to give the baby check-ups at home, saying it is too cold there; while it continues to snow sporadically, the family has run out of heating fuel.

Maternal and infant mortality rates have dropped significantly in Bayan Ulgii during the last decade, as they have globally, although progress is not a given: more of Bayan Ulgii’s mothers died during childbirth in 2009 than in 2008. Neither Bayan Ulgii’s hospital nor its economy seem likely to improve significantly in the near future. In the meantime, its people will carry on as they always have. Says the regional INGO health director, “I would say that Bayan Ulgii is very hardworking. That is the only reason they’re surviving.”


    Share

About the Author

Andrew Cullen

Andrew Cullen is a freelance photographer from New England. He worked as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Bangladesh and Mongolia for four years, and currently documents environment, health, and development issues in Mongolia. He is also a Spring 2010 Glimpse Correspondent.

7 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Josh replied on April 29, 2010

    Glad to hear that World Vision stepped up and contributed there…hope that’s just the first step. Nice photo journalism, Andrew. I hope you can go back in 5 years and find improvements.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • andrew cullen replied to Josh on April 30, 2010

      Hey Josh (and Nick), thanks. I hope that improvements are made in the region in the next few years too, although i have some reservations. Mongolia is set to develop quickly thanks to the growth of their mining sector, but the concentration of mining activity in the central and southern regions makes me think that places like Bayan Ulgii, on the edge of the country, will be at the end of a slow, trickle-down development process. But, like the article says, the people out here are tough as hell, and they’ve always been self-sufficient. They’ll get though it all.

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • Nick replied on April 30, 2010

    Informative and moving story – thanks for sharing this. The third picture from the end is heartbreaking, but the final one seems to offer some hope for the future.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • maya replied on May 1, 2010

    thanks for this eye-opening piece and evocative photos.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Meg Wirth replied on May 2, 2010

    What a great article. These photos are incredible! We are holding a photo contest in conjunction with the International Day of the Midwife and as part of an idea out of Australia/New Zealand to hold a 24 hour virtual day of the midwife! The winner will be announced at midnight May 5th!.

    http://www.flickr.com/groups/maternova/

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
    • andrew cullen replied to Meg Wirth on May 4, 2010

      That’s a great idea, Meg! Wish i had heard about it earlier! MIdwives do play a very important role in Mongolia’s maternal health care, and the lengths that some of them go to to help rural mothers in childbirth and emergencies are impressive, and inspiring.

      (Report comment)

      ↵ Reply
  • Luke Nye replied on May 9, 2010

    I visited Mongolia a few years ago, and a hospital in the central part of the country had the same problems with lack of equipment. They couldn’t use their oxygen tanks because they didn’t have a simple plastic mask. It seems crazy to think that healthcare can lack so much from the shortage of a few simple items or medicines.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment