Group and Ceremony: One Expat’s Experience With Japanese Culture

02/18/10  Print This Post Print This Post    12 Comments   Popular   Written by Tom Shuttleworth
  • Stumble It
  • Share

Photos: author

The food, the chopsticks, the no shoes rules : no big deal. But the group mentality?

The vice principle walks carefully up the steps to the stage. At the top he stops and bows to the Japanese flag that hangs above. I can’t tell if it’s a bow of reverence or resigned routine. He approaches the podium, stops and bows to us. The gesture is returned.

“The closing ceremony of the second semester, 2009, will now begin,” he announces. My heart sinks. Another ceremony.

Group and ceremony. Two words that resonate throughout Japan. Twin pillars of social order and well being. You don’t have to be in a formal institution like a school to see it. Take football. The Japanese national team is technically proficient, fit and well drilled, but they can’t score goals. At the business end of things nobody wants the ball. It gets passed around like a hot potato.

“Just hit the thing!” I scream at the TV.

But to do so would require a degree of selfishness that is hard to reach when the group is so important. It would be a disaster to miss.

Regard the fans at a Sumo match. See how the two giants hold them captive with a thrilling pre-fight ceremony where the stomping of feet and slapping of thighs draw rapturous applause. My first time watching I was tensed with anticipation that this was going to lead to a titanic battle. The fight was over in 30 seconds. What was all that about, I thought. Well, the ceremony, as it turns out.

Group and ceremony. They have been the hardest part of adjusting to life in Japan. The other stuff has all fallen into place comfortably: the food, the chopsticks, the careful choice of socks because I know my shoes will be taken off regularly in public. All of these differences I’ve met with wide eyed enthusiasm.

Photos: Sarah Menkedick

I adhere to the group and the ceremony, too, but it’s merely a physical display. Internally I’m still at odds with it. This is perhaps because it’s only recently that I’ve come to give it serious thought; my early days in Japan were spent enraptured with so many other aspects of place and culture.

At times it feels like my life is put on hold and my individual instincts and desires suppressed. My reactions to this are kept bottled up. Internally, they run the gauntlet from a head full of angry expletives to a simple resignation whereupon I want to fall to my knees and weep.

These values conflict with some key western values. The individual, restrained here, is encouraged in England where it’s good to be different. “Be all you can be.” “Do what you want when you want.” Just try not to tread on too many toes along the way. There is no standing on ceremony either; if something needs doing, get on and do it.

Here in Japan, though, even the simplest tasks can be wrapped in ceremony. Group observed ceremony: a cathartic experience in which we finish with one thing and move on to the other, collectively.

Of course I enjoy the benefits. I live in Tokyo, one of the world’s largest urban areas and also one of its safest. Group mentality helps to keep it that way. So it is that I walk the streets freely and confidently, anywhere, anytime.

The group may also serve to promote me as an individual. Here I can be, with relative ease, all of the things that I would have to fight for back home – a maverick, left field, original and funny.

But this freedom is a reflection of the truth that I am yet to be truly accepted here. Why should I be? I imagine most Japanese people I know expect me to return home sooner or later. But what if I don’t leave and more foreigners come to stay? How will the group react? How will new arrivals react? These are interesting questions as Japan increasingly looks to the international community for ideas and support.

A maverick! I like the sound of that. The other day I arrived at work to the big eighties sounds of a song from the movie Top Gun. It was playing out of the school’s loudspeakers in an attempt to liven us up. I chuckled and thought of Tom Cruise’s ‘Maverick’ character fighting against the strictures of the US air force. I wondered how he would fare in Japan.


  • Stumble It
  • Share

About the Author

Matador ID: toms

Tom Shuttleworth currently lives and works in Tokyo, Japan, where he spends his time surfing, trying to read kanji and seeking out novelty Japanese snacks. A philosophy graduate from the UK, he has travelled on five continents and dreams of return trip to Indonesia.

12 Comments... join the discussion!

  • Turner replied on February 19, 2010

    Great rundown. I don’t think Maverick would survive. Have you read You Gotta Have Wa?

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Tom Shuttleworth replied on February 20, 2010

    I think you’re right! Maybe Goose would get on better.

    You Gotta Have Wa – not read it. Tell me more…

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Tom Shuttleworth replied on February 20, 2010

    Ha! Maybe he’d need Goose with him to calm him down.

    Not read it. Tell me more….

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Adam Park replied on February 22, 2010

    Fantastic!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Jude replied on February 22, 2010

    Loved it….great article and well written.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Marie replied on February 22, 2010

    Nice piece, Tom. Yes, the ceremonies! And have you had to attend meetings in your job and learnt about the ceremony of the meeting? There is always a pre-meeting meeting in which the ceremony of the meeting is decided (sometimes even two or three)…but at least you always get tea!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Ryukyu Mike replied on February 22, 2010

    Great article. It reminded me of what I used to tell English conversation students:

    Americans have a saying, “The noisy wheel gets the grease”.

    Okinawans say, “The nail that sticks up gets the hammer” !

    Cheers,
    Mike

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Andy replied on February 28, 2010

    Great article! A fascinating view of Japanese culture.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Lorna replied on March 3, 2010

    Love the view on this, so true as well. I think you have to be indoctrinated in it all to understand it fully and participate entirely.

    I had the same feeling of anticlimax at the sumo – seriously? that was it?!

    The perfection element always jarred a little with me too – the folding and refolding of rubbish! Rubbish of all things! It took ages and all for the same out come.

    Irish saying: “What does it matter if it’s from a bowl or a saucepan, as long as you get a drink”

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Gill replied on March 10, 2010

    Interesting article, great insight.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Bob replied on May 9, 2010

    Hey Tom, it’s Principal, not principle!

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply
  • Hartini replied on July 9, 2010

    Yes, it was not easy to adjust from group mentality to the individualistic of the western society. People judge differently from one culture to another.

    (Report comment)

    ↵ Reply

Leave a Comment

Get Matador in your inbox and around the web.

Sign up for our FREE weekly newsletter.


View full list of RSS feeds

Jump To Category:


Travel Insurance.




Popular Stories on Matador

Tips for Travel Video: Framing the Action

What's the easiest technique you can use while filming ... 

The Ramen Rangers? CW Pilot Turns Backpackers Into CIA Operatives

The Backpacker's Bond is born. The CW and Ridley Scott ... 

5 Gifts For The World Traveler Who Needs Nothing

... 

How to Pack for a Semester Abroad

Bathing suit. . .check. Swiss Army knife. . .check. Pic... 

#MusicMonday: 50 Music Sites That Matter

Bored with your music collection? Feeling out of the m... 

Just How Big Is Alaska Anyway?

Contributing editor Juli Huang shows us in this overlay... 

BNT Makes an Appearance on 'The Colbert Report'

A highly debated article about fatism on BNT leads to a... 

Love In the Time of Matador: How'd I End Up Here With You?

Matador Life Editor Leigh Shulman talks about what it t... 

Technology and the Art of Location Independence

Matador catches up with professional travel writer/phot... 

Buenos Aires Binge Eating 101

We gave Tom Gates 24 hours to eat as much as he could s... 



Focus



Editor Blogs